Francesca Ludlam, from Grove Lane in Somersal Herbert, is a member of the British three-day eventing team and is training for 2012 Olympics. As part of her training she uses a training area,known as a menage, for 40 minutes per day.
But homeowners surrounding the sand-covered menage are upset about the noise made by her horse during the practice sessions and complained to Derbyshire Dales District Council.
Her father Michael has been battling to keep the menage since 2000, when a council enforcement notice ordered them to remove it.
They refused, and appealed against the decision, and a legal battle ensued that saw Mr Ludlam fighting for the menage’s use in the High Courts.
The arena has been used since 1985. In the late 1990s it was resurfaced to improve drainage, and land surrounding the arena was sold to nearby houses so they could extend their gardens.
Francesca said: "The land was sold on the agreement that the menage was there and would continue to be used.
"But in 2000 a complaint was made and we were told we would have to remove the sand surface and grow grass over the top.
"It’s the only flat area of land we’ve got, so I’ll still keep using it regardless, but I think a grass surface will be a lot more noisy than a sand surface, so it doesn’t make sense."
In her report to the planning committe, inspector Jean Jones said: "I have no doubt that there could be a disturbance to both adjoining occupiers at times when instructions are being given, maintenance carried out or people other than the rider are present.
"The council has not carried out a noise survey, but, given the sporadic nature of use, it would be difficult to do so.
"I consider the menage to be materially harmful to the living conditions of adjoining occupiers because of its proximity and use.
"It is sandwiched between their rear gardens which could expect to have more peace and privacy than frontages and the village is very small, with low levels of activity, so sounds will be noticeable."
The latest appeal decision was dismissed on February 13. Michael Ludlam said: "I’m very passionate about this, and will take it as high as it needs to go.
"We will now go to the High Court of Appeal again and, hopefully this time, will be allowed to keep the menage as it is."
I have been through a planning application for a menage and witnessed the same stupid arguements about noise. On that occassion the planning department dismissed the objections and I hope this will be the case here.
Perhaps the residents of Sommersal Herbert are not used to country life and should get back to the towns where they will no doubt have much more to moan about.
Chris Sabian,
Peak District View - 2007-03-13 05:49:12