Stancliffe Stone submitted an application to allow them to extract an extra 1.1 million tonnes of gritstone from Dale View Quarry in exchange for giving up all quarrying rights on Endcliffe and Lees Cross quarries.
Protesters against new quarrying, whilst agreeing with the principle of the landswop, do not feel that it is an equitable exchange and want to see the requested extraction amount reduced from 1.1 million tonnes to 650,000 tonnes.
In a packed Peak District National Park Authority planning meeting on Friday (16) the feeling amongst protesters was that the proposals were "greedy" and "obscene".
Alan Martin, chair of Stanton Peak Parish Council said: "The application put forward is good in principle but it is greedy.
"I am in favour of the application provided the right tonnage can be decided.
"Stancliffe have a number of advantages in quarrying at Dale View instead of Lees Cross and Endcliffe.
"The infrastructure required is already in place at Dale View and the cost of moving the protestors on from the other site would mean serious money, the estimated cost of moving on the Newbury Bypass protesters was around £50 million."
Keith Garton, a concerned resident, called for the curbing of extreme mineral and rock exploitation, calling it an "obscene destruction of the countryside."
He said :"I am concerned for the wellbeing of the community and the irreparable damage to local countryside and tourism.
"It is in your power to make sure that Stanton Moor remains a very special place in the National Park."
The committee voted to defer the application decision for further negotiation on lowering the extraction amounts.
Chair of the planning committee, Narendra Bajaria, said: "We sincerely hope that by working together we can reach an acceptable agreement on the area and amount of stone to be extracted from Dale View.
"The community representatives who attended the committee were not against the principle of an exchange and a consensus is starting to emerge."
Speaking after the meeting Councillor Anne Zoyroydi from Stanton In Peak Parish Council said: "We are absolutely thrilled to bits, we all thought this was a rubber stamped decision but it seems that the views of the community have been listened to.
"We want Stancliffe Stone to come back to the table with a lower extraction figure.
"The consolidated views of the community won the day, we all spoke with one voice. It is a great result and we are so pleased."
Geoff Henson from the Stanton Lees Action Group said: "We are surprised by the result but very pleased, we are delighted that sense prevailed.
"Now we want Stancliffe to come back with a more equitable exchange that will better benefit the community and the special landscape of the area."
So it's back to the trees for the eco warriers on Stanton Moor - for the time being anyway. Just watch out for the high winds and snow tomorrow!
Chris Sabian, Peak District View - 2007-03-17 02:02:58